| 1871 | William G. Sargent | 1900 | Courtney C. K. Scoville | |
| 1872 | Charles G. Scrafford | 1901-1902 | Ed Collins | |
| 1873 | Charles G. Scrafford | 1903-1904 | Mosses Noble | |
| 1874 | D. B. McKay | 1905-1906 | Andrew J. Felt | |
| 1875 | John H. Larew | 1907-1910 | J(acob) H. Cohen | |
| 1876 | Abijah Wells | 1911-1914 | W. G. Rucker | |
| 1877 | Abijah Wells | 1915-1918 | William Dennis | |
| 1878 | Robert E. Nelson | 1919-1920 | Joseph P. Koelzer | |
| 1879 | Robert E. Nelson | 1921-1924 | George H. Shaul | |
| 1880 | Edward Butt | 1925-1928 | Richard D. McCliman | |
| 1881 | John H. Larew | 1929-1932 | G. D. Myers | |
| 1882 |
J. H. Hatch (declined) Joshua Mitchell (elected) |
1933-1936 | Rufus M Emery, Jr. | |
| 1883 | Leopold Cohen | 1937-1947 | Jack R. Houston | |
| 1884 | John H. Larew | 1947-1969 | Gene Toby | |
| 1885 | Aaron H. Burnett | 1969-1971 | Joe Wichman | |
| 1886 | John A. Gilchrist | 1971-1973 | Bill H. Huerter | |
| 1887 | Charles G. Scrafford | 1973-1975 | Lawrence Schmidt | |
| 1888 | Charles G. Scrafford | 1975-1977 | Bill H. Huerter | |
| 1889-1991 | Walter Sperling | 1977-1983 | Lawrence Schmidt | |
| 1892 | Richard S. Robbins | 1983-1985 | Harold Mitchell | |
| 1892-1897 | James H. Gleason | 1985-1991 | Robert Claas | |
| 1898-1899 | Melville R. Connet | 1991-1995 | Bill L. Miller | |
| 1995- | George Heideman |